±Recent Visitors

Recent Visitors to Com-Central!

±User Info-big


Welcome Anonymous

Nickname
Password

Membership:
Latest: HighestAce
New Today: 0
New Yesterday: 0
Overall: 6648

People Online:
Members: 0
Visitors: 1046
Total: 1046
Who Is Where:
 Visitors:
01: Home
02: Home
03: Home
04: Community Forums
05: Community Forums
06: Community Forums
07: Community Forums
08: Community Forums
09: Member Screenshots
10: Community Forums
11: Member Screenshots
12: Community Forums
13: Community Forums
14: Home
15: Community Forums
16: Community Forums
17: Community Forums
18: Community Forums
19: Community Forums
20: Photo Gallery
21: Photo Gallery
22: Community Forums
23: Community Forums
24: Home
25: Community Forums
26: Member Screenshots
27: Downloads
28: News
29: Community Forums
30: Photo Gallery
31: Community Forums
32: Photo Gallery
33: News Archive
34: Member Screenshots
35: Community Forums
36: Photo Gallery
37: Downloads
38: Community Forums
39: Community Forums
40: Home
41: Community Forums
42: Community Forums
43: Photo Gallery
44: Community Forums
45: Community Forums
46: Member Screenshots
47: Community Forums
48: Community Forums
49: Photo Gallery
50: Community Forums
51: Community Forums
52: Member Screenshots
53: Community Forums
54: News Archive
55: Community Forums
56: Community Forums
57: Community Forums
58: Community Forums
59: Downloads
60: Community Forums
61: Home
62: Home
63: Home
64: Community Forums
65: Community Forums
66: Community Forums
67: News
68: Community Forums
69: Community Forums
70: Community Forums
71: Community Forums
72: Community Forums
73: Community Forums
74: Community Forums
75: Community Forums
76: Member Screenshots
77: Community Forums
78: Community Forums
79: Member Screenshots
80: Photo Gallery
81: Member Screenshots
82: Community Forums
83: Community Forums
84: Home
85: Photo Gallery
86: Downloads
87: Photo Gallery
88: Photo Gallery
89: Home
90: Community Forums
91: Community Forums
92: Home
93: Community Forums
94: Community Forums
95: Community Forums
96: Community Forums
97: Community Forums
98: News Archive
99: Home
100: Home
101: Home
102: Member Screenshots
103: Community Forums
104: Member Screenshots
105: Community Forums
106: Community Forums
107: Community Forums
108: Photo Gallery
109: Home
110: Member Screenshots
111: Community Forums
112: Community Forums
113: Community Forums
114: Home
115: Photo Gallery
116: Community Forums
117: Member Screenshots
118: Community Forums
119: Photo Gallery
120: Member Screenshots
121: Home
122: Community Forums
123: News Archive
124: Community Forums
125: Community Forums
126: Community Forums
127: Community Forums
128: Community Forums
129: Community Forums
130: Community Forums
131: Community Forums
132: Community Forums
133: Home
134: Photo Gallery
135: Community Forums
136: Community Forums
137: Photo Gallery
138: Community Forums
139: Member Screenshots
140: Home
141: News Archive
142: Home
143: Community Forums
144: Member Screenshots
145: Community Forums
146: News
147: Community Forums
148: Photo Gallery
149: Community Forums
150: Community Forums
151: Home
152: Community Forums
153: Community Forums
154: Community Forums
155: Community Forums
156: Community Forums
157: Community Forums
158: Photo Gallery
159: Search
160: Photo Gallery
161: Photo Gallery
162: Home
163: Member Screenshots
164: Community Forums
165: Home
166: Community Forums
167: Community Forums
168: Home
169: Community Forums
170: Downloads
171: Home
172: Community Forums
173: Community Forums
174: Member Screenshots
175: Community Forums
176: Home
177: Community Forums
178: Community Forums
179: Community Forums
180: Home
181: Photo Gallery
182: Member Screenshots
183: Community Forums
184: Home
185: Community Forums
186: Community Forums
187: Member Screenshots
188: Home
189: Home
190: News
191: Community Forums
192: News Archive
193: Photo Gallery
194: Community Forums
195: Member Screenshots
196: Home
197: Home
198: Community Forums
199: Community Forums
200: News Archive
201: Member Screenshots
202: Downloads
203: Home
204: Home
205: Community Forums
206: Community Forums
207: Community Forums
208: Community Forums
209: Member Screenshots
210: Home
211: Community Forums
212: Member Screenshots
213: Downloads
214: Community Forums
215: Community Forums
216: Home
217: Community Forums
218: Community Forums
219: Community Forums
220: Member Screenshots
221: Community Forums
222: Community Forums
223: Community Forums
224: Member Screenshots
225: Community Forums
226: Community Forums
227: Community Forums
228: Community Forums
229: Community Forums
230: Community Forums
231: Home
232: Your Account
233: Photo Gallery
234: Member Screenshots
235: Community Forums
236: Home
237: Community Forums
238: Community Forums
239: Photo Gallery
240: Member Screenshots
241: News Archive
242: Member Screenshots
243: Home
244: Home
245: Home
246: News
247: Photo Gallery
248: Community Forums
249: Home
250: Home
251: Community Forums
252: Community Forums
253: News
254: Community Forums
255: Community Forums
256: Community Forums
257: Downloads
258: Home
259: Community Forums
260: Home
261: Community Forums
262: Community Forums
263: Photo Gallery
264: Member Screenshots
265: Community Forums
266: Home
267: Home
268: Community Forums
269: Downloads
270: Community Forums
271: Community Forums
272: Home
273: Community Forums
274: Community Forums
275: Home
276: Home
277: Community Forums
278: Community Forums
279: Photo Gallery
280: Photo Gallery
281: Community Forums
282: Community Forums
283: Community Forums
284: Community Forums
285: Community Forums
286: Community Forums
287: Home
288: Community Forums
289: Downloads
290: News Archive
291: Photo Gallery
292: Photo Gallery
293: Member Screenshots
294: Community Forums
295: Community Forums
296: Community Forums
297: Community Forums
298: Home
299: Home
300: Community Forums
301: Community Forums
302: Downloads
303: Community Forums
304: Community Forums
305: Member Screenshots
306: Community Forums
307: Downloads
308: Community Forums
309: Community Forums
310: Community Forums
311: Community Forums
312: Home
313: Member Screenshots
314: Community Forums
315: Community Forums
316: Community Forums
317: News
318: Community Forums
319: Home
320: Community Forums
321: Community Forums
322: Member Screenshots
323: Community Forums
324: Community Forums
325: Community Forums
326: Community Forums
327: News Archive
328: Community Forums
329: Home
330: Community Forums
331: Community Forums
332: Community Forums
333: Community Forums
334: Photo Gallery
335: Downloads
336: Community Forums
337: Photo Gallery
338: Member Screenshots
339: Community Forums
340: Community Forums
341: Home
342: Community Forums
343: Community Forums
344: Community Forums
345: News
346: News Archive
347: Photo Gallery
348: Community Forums
349: Downloads
350: News Archive
351: Member Screenshots
352: Community Forums
353: Home
354: Community Forums
355: Community Forums
356: News Archive
357: Community Forums
358: Community Forums
359: Community Forums
360: Community Forums
361: Community Forums
362: Photo Gallery
363: Home
364: Community Forums
365: Community Forums
366: Home
367: Community Forums
368: Community Forums
369: Community Forums
370: News Archive
371: Member Screenshots
372: Community Forums
373: Downloads
374: Downloads
375: Home
376: Member Screenshots
377: Home
378: Statistics
379: Home
380: Home
381: Member Screenshots
382: Photo Gallery
383: Community Forums
384: Community Forums
385: Community Forums
386: Community Forums
387: Community Forums
388: Community Forums
389: Photo Gallery
390: Community Forums
391: Community Forums
392: Downloads
393: Community Forums
394: Community Forums
395: Photo Gallery
396: Community Forums
397: Member Screenshots
398: Community Forums
399: Member Screenshots
400: Downloads
401: Community Forums
402: Community Forums
403: Home
404: Community Forums
405: Community Forums
406: Member Screenshots
407: Photo Gallery
408: Community Forums
409: Community Forums
410: Community Forums
411: Photo Gallery
412: Home
413: Community Forums
414: Downloads
415: Home
416: Member Screenshots
417: Community Forums
418: Community Forums
419: Community Forums
420: Community Forums
421: Home
422: Downloads
423: Community Forums
424: Community Forums
425: Community Forums
426: Member Screenshots
427: Community Forums
428: Home
429: Community Forums
430: Community Forums
431: Community Forums
432: Community Forums
433: Community Forums
434: Community Forums
435: Community Forums
436: Community Forums
437: Community Forums
438: Community Forums
439: Photo Gallery
440: Member Screenshots
441: Community Forums
442: Community Forums
443: Community Forums
444: Home
445: Community Forums
446: Community Forums
447: Downloads
448: Home
449: Community Forums
450: Photo Gallery
451: Home
452: Member Screenshots
453: News Archive
454: Community Forums
455: Community Forums
456: Community Forums
457: Member Screenshots
458: Community Forums
459: Member Screenshots
460: Photo Gallery
461: Downloads
462: News Archive
463: News
464: Downloads
465: Member Screenshots
466: Community Forums
467: Community Forums
468: Community Forums
469: Photo Gallery
470: Member Screenshots
471: Member Screenshots
472: Community Forums
473: Home
474: Community Forums
475: Community Forums
476: Community Forums
477: Member Screenshots
478: Community Forums
479: Home
480: Home
481: Community Forums
482: Member Screenshots
483: Community Forums
484: Home
485: Community Forums
486: Community Forums
487: Community Forums
488: Community Forums
489: Community Forums
490: News Archive
491: Community Forums
492: Community Forums
493: Community Forums
494: Community Forums
495: Member Screenshots
496: Community Forums
497: Community Forums
498: News Archive
499: News Archive
500: Community Forums
501: Home
502: Community Forums
503: Community Forums
504: Photo Gallery
505: Community Forums
506: Downloads
507: Home
508: Community Forums
509: Home
510: Community Forums
511: Community Forums
512: Home
513: Member Screenshots
514: Community Forums
515: Downloads
516: Community Forums
517: Community Forums
518: Downloads
519: Photo Gallery
520: Community Forums
521: Community Forums
522: Community Forums
523: Community Forums
524: News Archive
525: Community Forums
526: Home
527: Home
528: Community Forums
529: Photo Gallery
530: Community Forums
531: Home
532: Community Forums
533: Photo Gallery
534: Community Forums
535: Community Forums
536: Member Screenshots
537: Member Screenshots
538: Community Forums
539: Community Forums
540: Home
541: Community Forums
542: Community Forums
543: Community Forums
544: Community Forums
545: Community Forums
546: Community Forums
547: Community Forums
548: Photo Gallery
549: Community Forums
550: News Archive
551: News
552: Community Forums
553: Photo Gallery
554: Community Forums
555: Community Forums
556: Member Screenshots
557: Community Forums
558: Community Forums
559: Community Forums
560: Community Forums
561: Member Screenshots
562: Member Screenshots
563: Community Forums
564: Community Forums
565: Community Forums
566: Community Forums
567: Member Screenshots
568: Contact
569: Member Screenshots
570: Community Forums
571: Community Forums
572: Community Forums
573: Statistics
574: Photo Gallery
575: Community Forums
576: Downloads
577: Community Forums
578: Community Forums
579: Community Forums
580: Community Forums
581: Community Forums
582: Community Forums
583: News Archive
584: Photo Gallery
585: Community Forums
586: Photo Gallery
587: Community Forums
588: Community Forums
589: Member Screenshots
590: Community Forums
591: Community Forums
592: Community Forums
593: Community Forums
594: Photo Gallery
595: News Archive
596: Home
597: Member Screenshots
598: Community Forums
599: Community Forums
600: Community Forums
601: News Archive
602: Photo Gallery
603: Member Screenshots
604: Home
605: Community Forums
606: Community Forums
607: Member Screenshots
608: Community Forums
609: News
610: Community Forums
611: Community Forums
612: Community Forums
613: Photo Gallery
614: Community Forums
615: Community Forums
616: Home
617: Community Forums
618: Community Forums
619: Downloads
620: Member Screenshots
621: Community Forums
622: Home
623: Member Screenshots
624: Home
625: Community Forums
626: Community Forums
627: Community Forums
628: Community Forums
629: News
630: Home
631: Community Forums
632: Community Forums
633: Community Forums
634: Downloads
635: Community Forums
636: Community Forums
637: Member Screenshots
638: Community Forums
639: Photo Gallery
640: Community Forums
641: Community Forums
642: Community Forums
643: Community Forums
644: News Archive
645: Member Screenshots
646: Member Screenshots
647: Community Forums
648: Downloads
649: Member Screenshots
650: Community Forums
651: Home
652: News Archive
653: Community Forums
654: Community Forums
655: Community Forums
656: Photo Gallery
657: Community Forums
658: Community Forums
659: Community Forums
660: Community Forums
661: Photo Gallery
662: Your Account
663: Community Forums
664: Community Forums
665: News Archive
666: News Archive
667: Community Forums
668: Photo Gallery
669: Home
670: Community Forums
671: Member Screenshots
672: News Archive
673: Home
674: Community Forums
675: Home
676: Community Forums
677: Home
678: Member Screenshots
679: Home
680: Community Forums
681: Community Forums
682: Home
683: Photo Gallery
684: Home
685: Your Account
686: Community Forums
687: Downloads
688: Community Forums
689: Downloads
690: Photo Gallery
691: Downloads
692: Community Forums
693: Home
694: Community Forums
695: Home
696: Home
697: Community Forums
698: Community Forums
699: Community Forums
700: Community Forums
701: Community Forums
702: Community Forums
703: Community Forums
704: Community Forums
705: Community Forums
706: Community Forums
707: News Archive
708: Community Forums
709: Community Forums
710: Community Forums
711: Community Forums
712: Community Forums
713: Community Forums
714: Downloads
715: Home
716: Downloads
717: Community Forums
718: Community Forums
719: Community Forums
720: Member Screenshots
721: Community Forums
722: Community Forums
723: Community Forums
724: Photo Gallery
725: Community Forums
726: Community Forums
727: Community Forums
728: Downloads
729: Photo Gallery
730: Photo Gallery
731: Community Forums
732: Community Forums
733: News Archive
734: Community Forums
735: Community Forums
736: Community Forums
737: Member Screenshots
738: Downloads
739: Community Forums
740: Community Forums
741: Community Forums
742: Photo Gallery
743: Home
744: Community Forums
745: Community Forums
746: Community Forums
747: Photo Gallery
748: Community Forums
749: Community Forums
750: Home
751: Community Forums
752: Community Forums
753: Photo Gallery
754: Community Forums
755: Community Forums
756: Community Forums
757: News Archive
758: Community Forums
759: Home
760: Home
761: Community Forums
762: Community Forums
763: Community Forums
764: Home
765: Home
766: Community Forums
767: Community Forums
768: Member Screenshots
769: Member Screenshots
770: Community Forums
771: Community Forums
772: Community Forums
773: Community Forums
774: Community Forums
775: Community Forums
776: Community Forums
777: Community Forums
778: Community Forums
779: Community Forums
780: Home
781: Statistics
782: News Archive
783: Photo Gallery
784: Community Forums
785: Member Screenshots
786: News Archive
787: Community Forums
788: Community Forums
789: Community Forums
790: Community Forums
791: Community Forums
792: Downloads
793: Community Forums
794: Photo Gallery
795: Community Forums
796: Home
797: Downloads
798: Community Forums
799: Downloads
800: Community Forums
801: Community Forums
802: Community Forums
803: Community Forums
804: Community Forums
805: News Archive
806: Community Forums
807: Community Forums
808: Community Forums
809: Member Screenshots
810: Community Forums
811: Community Forums
812: Community Forums
813: Photo Gallery
814: Community Forums
815: News Archive
816: News Archive
817: Home
818: Photo Gallery
819: Community Forums
820: Community Forums
821: News Archive
822: Member Screenshots
823: Community Forums
824: Community Forums
825: Community Forums
826: Community Forums
827: Community Forums
828: Photo Gallery
829: Community Forums
830: Community Forums
831: Community Forums
832: Community Forums
833: Community Forums
834: Community Forums
835: Community Forums
836: Home
837: Home
838: Community Forums
839: Photo Gallery
840: Community Forums
841: Community Forums
842: News Archive
843: Community Forums
844: Community Forums
845: Community Forums
846: Home
847: Member Screenshots
848: Downloads
849: Community Forums
850: Photo Gallery
851: Community Forums
852: Community Forums
853: Community Forums
854: Community Forums
855: Community Forums
856: Community Forums
857: Downloads
858: Community Forums
859: Downloads
860: Community Forums
861: Community Forums
862: Home
863: Member Screenshots
864: Community Forums
865: Member Screenshots
866: Community Forums
867: Member Screenshots
868: Photo Gallery
869: Home
870: News Archive
871: Community Forums
872: Community Forums
873: Home
874: Community Forums
875: Community Forums
876: News Archive
877: Community Forums
878: Community Forums
879: Home
880: Community Forums
881: Community Forums
882: Community Forums
883: Community Forums
884: Community Forums
885: Member Screenshots
886: Community Forums
887: Photo Gallery
888: Downloads
889: Home
890: Home
891: Photo Gallery
892: Photo Gallery
893: Community Forums
894: Member Screenshots
895: News Archive
896: Community Forums
897: Community Forums
898: Community Forums
899: Community Forums
900: Community Forums
901: Community Forums
902: Photo Gallery
903: Community Forums
904: Home
905: Community Forums
906: Home
907: Member Screenshots
908: Community Forums
909: Community Forums
910: Photo Gallery
911: Downloads
912: Home
913: Community Forums
914: Downloads
915: Community Forums
916: Member Screenshots
917: News Archive
918: Community Forums
919: Community Forums
920: Community Forums
921: Community Forums
922: Community Forums
923: Community Forums
924: Community Forums
925: Member Screenshots
926: Community Forums
927: Community Forums
928: Community Forums
929: Home
930: Community Forums
931: Your Account
932: Community Forums
933: Community Forums
934: Community Forums
935: News
936: News
937: Community Forums
938: Community Forums
939: Home
940: Photo Gallery
941: Member Screenshots
942: Community Forums
943: Member Screenshots
944: Member Screenshots
945: Community Forums
946: Community Forums
947: Photo Gallery
948: Community Forums
949: Community Forums
950: Community Forums
951: News
952: Community Forums
953: News Archive
954: Downloads
955: Community Forums
956: Community Forums
957: Member Screenshots
958: Member Screenshots
959: Community Forums
960: Community Forums
961: Home
962: Community Forums
963: Community Forums
964: News Archive
965: Community Forums
966: Community Forums
967: Community Forums
968: Community Forums
969: Community Forums
970: Community Forums
971: Community Forums
972: Community Forums
973: Member Screenshots
974: Community Forums
975: Community Forums
976: Community Forums
977: Community Forums
978: Community Forums
979: Member Screenshots
980: Community Forums
981: Community Forums
982: Community Forums
983: Community Forums
984: Community Forums
985: Community Forums
986: Member Screenshots
987: Community Forums
988: Member Screenshots
989: Community Forums
990: Photo Gallery
991: Community Forums
992: Community Forums
993: Community Forums
994: Community Forums
995: Community Forums
996: Community Forums
997: Community Forums
998: Downloads
999: Community Forums
1000: Downloads
1001: Member Screenshots
1002: Community Forums
1003: Community Forums
1004: Community Forums
1005: Community Forums
1006: Community Forums
1007: Community Forums
1008: Community Forums
1009: Home
1010: Community Forums
1011: Photo Gallery
1012: Community Forums
1013: Member Screenshots
1014: Community Forums
1015: Downloads
1016: Community Forums
1017: Community Forums
1018: Your Account
1019: Home
1020: Downloads
1021: Community Forums
1022: Member Screenshots
1023: Photo Gallery
1024: Community Forums
1025: Downloads
1026: Home
1027: Community Forums
1028: Community Forums
1029: Community Forums
1030: Community Forums
1031: Home
1032: Photo Gallery
1033: Statistics
1034: Member Screenshots
1035: Home
1036: Home
1037: Community Forums
1038: Photo Gallery
1039: Community Forums
1040: Member Screenshots
1041: Community Forums
1042: Community Forums
1043: Home
1044: Photo Gallery
1045: Community Forums
1046: News Archive

Staff Online:

No staff members are online!
Tiger I – pathetic reliability?
The AFV ASSOCIATION was formed in 1964 to support the thoughts and research of all those interested in Armored Fighting Vehicles and related topics, such as AFV drawings. The emphasis has always been on sharing information and communicating with other members of similar interests; e.g. German armor, Japanese AFVs, or whatever.
Post new topic    Reply to topic    Printer Friendly Page     Forum Index ›  AFV News Discussion Board

View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
lehr
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Feb 24, 2006
Posts: 7

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 6:16 pm
Post subject: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

This was posted on a forum on BoardGameGeek (I have the quote below so you do not have to use the link - for some reason BGG web pages can take a long time to download).

Geek List: wargames worth pre-ordering

The game’s designer gives some history of one of the units:

BTW, a little history of that counter....

That counter is schwere Panzer-Kompanie Hummel (K.St.N. 1176(f.g)) and was equipped with 14 PzKpfw VI Tiger Is...

It was formed in July 1944 at the Pz.Ers.Abt.500 in Paderborn, Germany as an "Alarmeinheit". After recovering from wounds in Italy, Hauptmann Hans Hummel was placed in command. Hummel selected his subcommanders available at PzErsAbt 500 from the officers present he knew from fighting in Italy with Pz.Abt 504.

His unit was alerted at around 12:30am on September 18th and was ordered to report to the Arnhem area. The unit arrived at Bocholt station on the morning of the 19th.

With the rail line blocked from allied air interdiction and other traffic proceeding in both directions, and with no tank transporters available, Hummel was ordered to proceed the 80 kms with the Tigers under their own power.

Tigers, as many of you might know, are not the most reliable of tanks under heavy use and all but 2 broke down during the trip. The two lucky tanks to make the trip without braking down were commanded by Leutnant Knaack and Feldwebel Barneki. They arrived around nightfall of the 19th at the Arnhem bridge perimeter.

The entire unit was not fully formed until the 24th - sans 3 Tigers.


Only 2 out of 14 Tiger Is (14%) made the 80km (50 mile) trip without breakdown. Compared with many other theaters of WWII, Holland in September does not seem like it would have the most demanding terrain or weather.

Is this reliability typical of Tiger Is?

What about other WWII tanks?

If 14 Shermans set out on the same trip how many would make it without breaking down?

What about 14 T-34s?

What about 14 AFVs with which you have personal experience (including post WWII)?

I am sure a lot depends on the condition of the tanks at the start of the trip, but the above performance just seems really bad. It seems like reliability like this would greatly reduce the effectiveness of an AFV especially on the offensive.

Any comments, knowledge and experience greatly appreciated.
Back to top
View user's profile
Sabot
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 380
Location: Kentucky
PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 7:54 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

The Tiger got a bad reputation (mechanically) at Kursk because they were deployed without first working all of the bugs out of them. Additionally, in wintery muddy weather, the mud would freeze between the road wheels overnight and immobilize the tank.

It also suffered from poor fuel consumption. I do not know the range of the tank off hand, but I believe it was less than 100 miles.

The Sherman was a mechanically sound vehicle and a 50 mile trip would have been easy to accomplish. The Sherman came with about four different engine types and fuel efficiency and reliability depended on which engine was being used.

_________________
RobG
Back to top
View user's profile AIM Address
PattonCurator
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 1

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 8:38 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

Agree about the Shermans - very reliable - probably 13 of the 14 would make the 50 mile trip (and the 14th would probably make it late after the crew repaired it. The T34 also has the same rugged reliability.

Charles
Back to top
View user's profile
Dubliner
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 94

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 9:55 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

nt


Last edited by Dubliner on Sat Mar 24, 2007 2:06 pm; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
View user's profile
clausb
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 25, 2006
Posts: 146

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 10:45 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

- lehr
Only 2 out of 14 Tiger Is (14%) made the 80km (50 mile) trip without breakdown. Compared with many other theaters of WWII, Holland in September does not seem like it would have the most demanding terrain or weather.

Is this reliability typical of Tiger Is?


The Tiger was a heavy and fairly complicated vehicle which needed a lot of maintenance to operate properly. IIRC the operation manuals for the Tiger states that the crew has to check a number of things on the vehicle for every 15km of road march and fix any problems encountered. So you need crews that know their mount, you need conditions that allows the crew to take care of the vehicle and of course you need spares and maintenance units to fix any problems that occur during the roadmarch. Once you start removing some of those prerequisites for keeping your Tiger happy, chances are there will be trouble.

Tigers of s.SS-PzAbt 101 travelled about 300 kilometers on the road from Northern France to Normandy in June 1944, starting out with 45 tanks on June 7th and was down to 17 operational Tigers on June 12th. Most of the reminder had broken down along the road. It is evident that once tanks start to brake down along a 300 kilometer journey, it is impossible for the maintenance company to help everyone and things will start to fall apart. I has to be said that this battalion did come under allied air attack as well, which clearly didn't help the situation any. AFAIK no Tigers were lossed to allied airpower until June 13th.
A major problem for s.SS-PzAbt 101 was that their new Tiges used the steel-rimmed wheels which were very hard on the tracks, particularily the tracks pins, when travelling on hard surfaces.

IIRC Kompanie Hummel took over their Tigers from Pz.Ers.u.Ausb.Abt 500, a training formation, so they might have been well used vehicles to begin with.

- lehr
What about other WWII tanks?

If 14 Shermans set out on the same trip how many would make it without breaking down?

What about 14 T-34s?


WWII tanks were generally fragile beasts compared with modern equipment, but neither the Sherman nor the T-34 were as heavy and complex as the Tiger I. They would probably suffer a lot less from the strains of a long roadmarch and the Sherman in particular would benefit from its rubber rimmed wheels and rubber-bushed track pins.

That said, T-34s were not really known for their production quality or reliability, at least through parts of the war, so my money would be on the Sherman as the more reliable, everything else being equal.

- lehr
I am sure a lot depends on the condition of the tanks at the start of the trip, but the above performance just seems really bad. It seems like reliability like this would greatly reduce the effectiveness of an AFV especially on the offensive.


Indeed. But I think we have to keep in mind the day and age of these machines. In WWI, you could start with 400 tanks and in a couple of days you would have very few left in operational condition, the rest being mostly broken down or stuck rather than destroyed. That lesson was carried over to WWII which is why early war German armoured divisions had up to 350 tanks. That way they could afford to have half of them out of order and still pack a punch. That was clearly demonstrated during the Battle for France when a division could drop to 50% of its strength in a few days of operation and then raise the figure to 80% after a day or two of maintenance and repair.

My 2 ørers worth anyway

Claus B

PS: Sabot, the Tiger was first employed around Leningrad in November 1942, I think you are confusing it with the Panther, which had some serious issues during its combat debut at Kursk in 1943 (and several months after that as well, but that's a different issue).
Back to top
View user's profile
mike_Duplessis
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 236

PostPosted: Wed Mar 01, 2006 6:22 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

I rather wonder if it was less a problem with the Tigers and more a problem with German maintenance units. You hear about American tank maintenance units doing heroic work all night long in order to get the tanks back up and running in the morning. Now that i recall, the book "Deathtraps" had some especially nasty things to say about the original Sherman radial engine. In that book I recall he broke-down what proportion of men in a Tank Battalion were involved in vehicle maintenance, and it was a grotesquely large number. By '44 Germany probably couldn't afford the manpower for an effective maintenance section.
Back to top
View user's profile
J.McGillivray
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 149

PostPosted: Wed Mar 01, 2006 10:47 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

The following is from “German Tanks of World War II� by Dr. S. Hart and Dr. R. Hart.(p.123-124)

“One engagement, during the 1944 Allied campaign in Italy, highlights the difficulties the Germans faced thanks to the poor cross-country performance, mechanical unreliability and the sheer physical bulk of the Tiger I tank. Between 23 and 25 May 1944, the 16Tigers of the 3rd Company, 506th Heavy Tank Battalion fought a costly engagement around Cori. On 23 May, the company advanced across a railway embankment and engaged Allied armour, but during the crossing three Tigers were disabled, two with track problems and one with gearbox failure. The Tiger's 2.02m (6ft Sin) barrel-overhang also proved a problem, as two other Tiger tanks accidentally jammed their guns into the soil as they came down the steep-sided embankment and had to be towed clear. Eventually 13 Tigers continued the advance during which they knocked out six Sherman tanks. During this attack, however, Allied artillery damaged another Tiger which withdrew back to a German workshop. The next day Allied anti-tank fire disabled another Tiger which was blown up by its crew.

“The company was then ordered to withdraw. While five Tigers held back an Allied attack, the remaining six tanks tried to tow away the three disabled Tigers by the embankment. However, the strain caused four of the six towing Tigers to break down. The Germans then had to destroy the three disabled tanks by the embankment and use the remaining two Tigers to tow back the four that had broken down. By the time the company had withdrawn to Cori, two of its five rearguard tanks had been disabled (one by Allied fire and the other because of a gearbox fault) while one of the two towing tanks had also broken down. Hence, while the three operational rearguard Tigers continued to block the Allied advance, back at Cori the company commander could deploy just one working Tiger and six disabled ones. With the rearguard now unable to stop the Allied advance into Cori, and with recovery vehicles unable to reach the company in time, the commander ordered the destruction of the six disabled Tigers to prevent them falling into Allied hands, while his remaining four tanks withdrew north. The company had lost 12 Tigers, but only three had been disabled by Allied fire. Clearly, the Tiger's mechanical unreliability was more of a threat than Allied fire.�
Back to top
View user's profile
Dontos
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 3436
Location: Vine Grove, KY
PostPosted: Wed Mar 01, 2006 11:54 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

As a career Tanker, I can only imagine the utter frustration of the crews. Knowing that they man such a powerful vehicle, but having to 'scuttle' them due to mechanical unreliability.

_________________
"Gonna hold my breath until Armor returns home..."
Back to top
View user's profile Send e-mail Visit poster's website AIM Address Yahoo Messenger Photo Gallery
clausb
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 25, 2006
Posts: 146

PostPosted: Fri Mar 03, 2006 6:53 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

- J.McGillivray
The following is from “German Tanks of World War II� by Dr. S. Hart and Dr. R. Hart.(p.123-124)

“One engagement, during the 1944 Allied campaign in Italy, highlights the difficulties the Germans faced thanks to the poor cross-country performance, mechanical unreliability and the sheer physical bulk of the Tiger I tank. Between 23 and 25 May 1944, the 16Tigers of the 3rd Company, 506th Heavy Tank Battalion fought a costly engagement around Cori.


In all fairness, this particular example is one of the worst performances of a Tiger unit and hardly typical. The unit was 3. Kompanie s.PzAbt 508 and there are at least two different accounts of what happened.

The company was caught in the middle of a major allied advance and apparently had no backup from the battalion maintenance company which had the heavy recovery vehicles. In the end, tanks with even minor damage, combat or mechanical, had to blown up or left to the enemy as the allies were advancing past the damaged vehicles. In such situations, armour losses are always high, regardless of type.

If you look at the incident, you start with three tanks breaking down on May 23rd. Two threw their tracks, which was not, to my knowledge, a common complaint with the Tiger, so it should probably not be put down to unreliability but rather accident (bad maintenance, bad driving, bad terriain or bad luck). One had transmission trouble, which is more like the kind of fault you would ascribe to mechanical deficiencies.

Then they try to recover the three broken down tanks by towing them after six other Tigers. AFAIK this procedure was actually forbidden unless there was imminent danger of the damaged tank falling into enemy hands. Tigers were not designed for such work, they had enough trouble shifting their own weight around.
Here the stories start to differ. In the Hart & Hart account, four of the towing tanks brakes down with transmission damage and one additional tank brakes down towing while two Tigers are trying to tow four other Tigers - a somewhat dubious claim, I think! In any case, this means that five Tigers broke down with transmission damage from towing.
In the report quoted by Jentz, four tanks of the six towing brakes down and then gets towed in turn by four other Tigers. These four Tigers make it, but later two of them brakes down transmission damage as well and it is tempting to assume that this had to do with the fact that they had been acting as recovery vehicles for most of the day. Another one of these four also brakes down later in the day with unspecified "technical problems".

Hart & Hart mentions another, non-towing Tiger braking down with transmission trouble later as well, which makes it two "unprovoked" transmission failures. In the Jentz account, you can argue that only one tank suffered from "unprovoked" transmission trouble while all the others broke down because of misuse.

When the allied forces neared the collection point for the damaged vehicles, the Tigers were blown up - six according to Hart & Hart, nine according to the Jentz report.

One could argue that if the company had the support from the necessary recovery vehicles, they might have lost between five and seven fewer tanks, namely those that broke down trying to recover the other losses.

During its time in Italy prior to this incident (from mid-february), the battalion managed to keep about 57% of its vehicles operational on average, with a low of 17% and a high of 93%. And it did see a fair amount of combat in the period.

Bottom line is that I think this story is more about the Tigers mechanical fragility than it unreliability. It did not stand up well to abuse, but does that make it unreliable? And of course it speaks of the problems involved in being overrun by the enemy!

Claus B
Back to top
View user's profile
lehr
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Feb 24, 2006
Posts: 7

PostPosted: Thu Mar 09, 2006 5:52 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

Thanks to all for your replies. It's easy to see the importance of firepower, armor and mobility, but now I have a greater appreciation for the importance of reliability and maintenance support.
Back to top
View user's profile
Dirk
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 115
Location: South Africa
PostPosted: Thu Mar 09, 2006 6:26 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

great thread - interesting discussion .

My 2 cents - The Tiger did the job it was designed for and thus could perhaps be viewed as a success.

Only thing was that the support system for the Tiger was not implemented , IIRC from a post-graduate course in Logistics Engineering I had :

Support the design and design the support .

My humble opinion Wink

Dirk
Back to top
View user's profile
mike_Duplessis
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 236

PostPosted: Thu Mar 09, 2006 7:31 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

One problem the late Tiger II chassis' had to worry about that I don't think the early Tiger I chassis did was slave labor teams being forced to assemble them. I recall (working of distant memory here) there's an account in the big 653rd book of Jadgtigers leaving the factory near war's en and hardly making it 40 miles out of town before most of them had broken down. It seems the radiators were so shoddily constructed that coolant flow was drastically restricted, quickly causing breakdowns due to overheating. It's tempting to imagine a heroic slave laborer risking death while purposefully soldering the radiators half-shut.

Its funny comparing this discussion with contemporary Allied accounts of German armor. It seems the grass in always greener on the other side. From the U.S. side the German tanks appeared to have better flotation (ground pressure), maneuverability, optics, armor, guns, engines (compared to the old radial), and pretty much everything else! Well, The U.S. tankers did prefer their own radios, turret drives, and HC smoke shell. But that's about it.
Back to top
View user's profile
clausb
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 25, 2006
Posts: 146

PostPosted: Fri Mar 10, 2006 2:47 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

- mike_Duplessis
One problem the late Tiger II chassis' had to worry about that I don't think the early Tiger I chassis did was slave labor teams being forced to assemble them. I recall (working of distant memory here) there's an account in the big 653rd book of Jadgtigers leaving the factory near war's en and hardly making it 40 miles out of town before most of them had broken down. It seems the radiators were so shoddily constructed that coolant flow was drastically restricted, quickly causing breakdowns due to overheating. It's tempting to imagine a heroic slave laborer risking death while purposefully soldering the radiators half-shut.


Or just doing sloppy work due to lack of training, skill, and motivation. But definately a factor - in one German plant (MAN Nürnberg), 55% of the work was made by foreign labour, non-Germans drafted as workers in the occupied countries.

- mike_Duplessis
Its funny comparing this discussion with contemporary Allied accounts of German armor. It seems the grass in always greener on the other side. From the U.S. side the German tanks appeared to have better flotation (ground pressure), maneuverability, optics, armor, guns, engines (compared to the old radial), and pretty much everything else! Well, The U.S. tankers did prefer their own radios, turret drives, and HC smoke shell. But that's about it.


That is really a different issue. Reliability, logistics and production concerns probably becomes a moot point if you are in the field, looking down the barrel of a bigger and badder enemy tank. On the other hand, if reliability, logistics and production does not work, you wont even have a tank, at least not at working one Smile

Claus B
Back to top
View user's profile
J.McGillivray
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 24, 2006
Posts: 149

PostPosted: Sat Mar 11, 2006 3:31 pm
Post subject: Re: Tiger I – pathetic reliability?

Robin Neillands in his book “The Desert Rats 7th Armoured Division 1940 – 1945� sums things up nicely as followers:

“At this point it may be necessary to explain to a section of the readership that the successful development of a new weapon is far from being the end of the story. The weapon will have a designed range of technical features and benefits, but at least half the effectiveness of any weapon in battle will depend on how it is used, manned, serviced and deployed in battle….. How a weapon is used is therefore as critical to its success as its designed technical performance.�

People who sing the praises of the German cats often talk of their performance under ideal theoretical conditions; although those conditions were seldom encountered in the field. One must take into consideration the actual conditions there the cats were used, or misused.

For example the Panthers with their excellent gun and well sloped armoured, were often thrown into reckless, rushed, poorly planned and poorly supported counter attacks, in Normandy; which exposed the weaknesses of their design.

The most important fact that one must consider is that the Germans, in spite of their Tigers and Panthers, still lost the war. In other words the big cats failed to get the job done!
Back to top
View user's profile
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic    Reply to topic    Printer Friendly Page    Forum Index ›  AFV News Discussion Board
Page 1 of 1
All times are GMT - 6 Hours



Jump to:  


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You cannot download files in this forum