±Recent Visitors

Recent Visitors to Com-Central!

±User Info-big


Welcome Anonymous

Nickname
Password

Membership:
Latest: HighestAce
New Today: 0
New Yesterday: 0
Overall: 6648

People Online:
Members: 1
Visitors: 384
Total: 385
Who Is Where:
 Members:
01: Shades > Community Forums
 Visitors:
01: Home
02: Home
03: Your Account
04: Photo Gallery
05: Photo Gallery
06: Community Forums
07: Photo Gallery
08: Community Forums
09: Community Forums
10: Statistics
11: Home
12: Member Screenshots
13: Community Forums
14: Statistics
15: Member Screenshots
16: Member Screenshots
17: Photo Gallery
18: News Archive
19: Photo Gallery
20: Community Forums
21: Member Screenshots
22: Community Forums
23: Member Screenshots
24: Photo Gallery
25: News Archive
26: Home
27: Home
28: Home
29: Community Forums
30: News Archive
31: Community Forums
32: Member Screenshots
33: Member Screenshots
34: Community Forums
35: Photo Gallery
36: Home
37: Downloads
38: Community Forums
39: Community Forums
40: Downloads
41: Community Forums
42: Home
43: Member Screenshots
44: Downloads
45: Member Screenshots
46: Member Screenshots
47: Downloads
48: Downloads
49: News Archive
50: Home
51: Photo Gallery
52: Home
53: Member Screenshots
54: Community Forums
55: Home
56: Home
57: Member Screenshots
58: Member Screenshots
59: Photo Gallery
60: Home
61: Home
62: Member Screenshots
63: Member Screenshots
64: Home
65: Community Forums
66: Member Screenshots
67: Community Forums
68: Home
69: Photo Gallery
70: Downloads
71: Community Forums
72: Community Forums
73: Home
74: Photo Gallery
75: Member Screenshots
76: Member Screenshots
77: Home
78: Member Screenshots
79: Member Screenshots
80: Photo Gallery
81: Member Screenshots
82: Community Forums
83: News Archive
84: Community Forums
85: Downloads
86: Downloads
87: Community Forums
88: News Archive
89: Community Forums
90: Member Screenshots
91: Community Forums
92: Community Forums
93: Member Screenshots
94: Home
95: Community Forums
96: Photo Gallery
97: Community Forums
98: Community Forums
99: Photo Gallery
100: Home
101: Community Forums
102: News
103: Member Screenshots
104: Home
105: Photo Gallery
106: Community Forums
107: Home
108: Community Forums
109: Community Forums
110: News Archive
111: Member Screenshots
112: Downloads
113: Member Screenshots
114: Community Forums
115: Your Account
116: Home
117: Statistics
118: Community Forums
119: Home
120: Member Screenshots
121: Photo Gallery
122: Home
123: Photo Gallery
124: Home
125: Home
126: Member Screenshots
127: Statistics
128: Community Forums
129: Home
130: Community Forums
131: Community Forums
132: Photo Gallery
133: Downloads
134: Community Forums
135: News Archive
136: Photo Gallery
137: Member Screenshots
138: Your Account
139: Community Forums
140: Community Forums
141: Community Forums
142: Home
143: Community Forums
144: Community Forums
145: Member Screenshots
146: Home
147: Member Screenshots
148: Member Screenshots
149: Member Screenshots
150: Community Forums
151: Photo Gallery
152: Member Screenshots
153: Community Forums
154: Home
155: Community Forums
156: Your Account
157: Home
158: Member Screenshots
159: Photo Gallery
160: Community Forums
161: Downloads
162: Downloads
163: News Archive
164: Member Screenshots
165: Community Forums
166: Home
167: Member Screenshots
168: Community Forums
169: Photo Gallery
170: Community Forums
171: Community Forums
172: Member Screenshots
173: Home
174: Home
175: Home
176: News Archive
177: Community Forums
178: Photo Gallery
179: Community Forums
180: Your Account
181: Home
182: Home
183: Community Forums
184: Member Screenshots
185: Community Forums
186: Your Account
187: Member Screenshots
188: Community Forums
189: Member Screenshots
190: Community Forums
191: Home
192: Community Forums
193: Home
194: Community Forums
195: Downloads
196: Photo Gallery
197: Community Forums
198: Community Forums
199: Home
200: Statistics
201: Home
202: Home
203: Community Forums
204: Member Screenshots
205: Community Forums
206: Photo Gallery
207: Downloads
208: News Archive
209: News Archive
210: Your Account
211: Community Forums
212: Photo Gallery
213: Community Forums
214: Home
215: Member Screenshots
216: Home
217: Member Screenshots
218: Home
219: Community Forums
220: Home
221: Member Screenshots
222: Community Forums
223: Community Forums
224: Photo Gallery
225: Community Forums
226: Member Screenshots
227: Your Account
228: Downloads
229: Member Screenshots
230: Home
231: Community Forums
232: Home
233: News Archive
234: Home
235: Community Forums
236: Home
237: Downloads
238: Community Forums
239: Community Forums
240: Community Forums
241: Photo Gallery
242: Community Forums
243: Member Screenshots
244: Your Account
245: Downloads
246: Home
247: Home
248: Home
249: Community Forums
250: Member Screenshots
251: Community Forums
252: Member Screenshots
253: Home
254: Photo Gallery
255: Member Screenshots
256: Member Screenshots
257: Photo Gallery
258: Community Forums
259: Your Account
260: Photo Gallery
261: Your Account
262: Community Forums
263: Community Forums
264: Community Forums
265: Home
266: Home
267: Home
268: Community Forums
269: Member Screenshots
270: Photo Gallery
271: Photo Gallery
272: News Archive
273: Your Account
274: Community Forums
275: Home
276: Photo Gallery
277: Member Screenshots
278: Member Screenshots
279: Home
280: Community Forums
281: Community Forums
282: Home
283: Home
284: Member Screenshots
285: Community Forums
286: Member Screenshots
287: Community Forums
288: Member Screenshots
289: Home
290: Community Forums
291: Member Screenshots
292: Member Screenshots
293: News
294: Downloads
295: Home
296: Member Screenshots
297: Home
298: Community Forums
299: Member Screenshots
300: Member Screenshots
301: Home
302: Community Forums
303: Photo Gallery
304: Home
305: Community Forums
306: Photo Gallery
307: Community Forums
308: Community Forums
309: Community Forums
310: Photo Gallery
311: Home
312: Downloads
313: Community Forums
314: Home
315: Community Forums
316: Your Account
317: Member Screenshots
318: Member Screenshots
319: Community Forums
320: Community Forums
321: Home
322: News Archive
323: Photo Gallery
324: News Archive
325: Member Screenshots
326: Community Forums
327: Community Forums
328: Home
329: Home
330: Home
331: Member Screenshots
332: Community Forums
333: Home
334: Member Screenshots
335: Photo Gallery
336: Member Screenshots
337: Member Screenshots
338: Statistics
339: Home
340: Community Forums
341: Home
342: Community Forums
343: Statistics
344: Community Forums
345: Photo Gallery
346: Community Forums
347: Community Forums
348: Community Forums
349: Photo Gallery
350: Downloads
351: Community Forums
352: Community Forums
353: Member Screenshots
354: Photo Gallery
355: Community Forums
356: Home
357: Member Screenshots
358: Home
359: Member Screenshots
360: Home
361: Member Screenshots
362: Community Forums
363: Photo Gallery
364: Home
365: Downloads
366: Photo Gallery
367: Community Forums
368: Community Forums
369: Community Forums
370: Member Screenshots
371: Community Forums
372: Photo Gallery
373: Member Screenshots
374: Member Screenshots
375: Community Forums
376: Member Screenshots
377: Photo Gallery
378: Community Forums
379: Community Forums
380: Member Screenshots
381: Member Screenshots
382: Your Account
383: Community Forums
384: Community Forums

Staff Online:

No staff members are online!
Question for the Sherman gurus...
The AFV ASSOCIATION was formed in 1964 to support the thoughts and research of all those interested in Armored Fighting Vehicles and related topics, such as AFV drawings. The emphasis has always been on sharing information and communicating with other members of similar interests; e.g. German armor, Japanese AFVs, or whatever.
Go to page Previous  1, 2
Post new topic    Reply to topic    Printer Friendly Page     Forum Index ›  AFV News Discussion Board

View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Hanno_Spoelstra
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jun 04, 2006
Posts: 185

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 1:10 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

The line is thin but clearly visible in my opinion: the starting point is the gun. Firefly is a popular name for the Sherman tanks converted with a 17-pdr AT gun. So, if no 17-pdr gun, the Sherman is not a Firefly.

Of course Trevor can use any set of rules to categorize his database. After people start swapping hulls, turrets, guns, engines, in my database I simple refer to those hodgepodge tanks as "Sherman", as they are nothing more than that. And for many people it is enough to see "a Sherman tank".

Hanno
Back to top
View user's profile
Massimo_Foti
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Apr 08, 2008
Posts: 5397
Location: Lugano, Switzerland
PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 1:14 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

- Hanno_Spoelstra
So, if no 17-pdr gun, the Sherman is not a Firefly.


What about an original 17-pdr gun turret on top of an hull that spots none of the Firefly's unique features, like the revised ammo storage?
Back to top
View user's profile
Hanno_Spoelstra
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jun 04, 2006
Posts: 185

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 4:12 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

- Massimo_Foti
What about an original 17-pdr gun turret on top of an hull that spots none of the Firefly's unique features, like the revised ammo storage?


That I would describe as "a Sherman" Wink

As a curator I would place a sign describing of which components this Sherman was made up of, and why. I would definitely not label this as a "Sherman Firefly" but a M4A(x) Medium Tank with a Firefly turret, or even, a turret with 17-pdr gun.
Back to top
View user's profile
Massimo_Foti
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Apr 08, 2008
Posts: 5397
Location: Lugano, Switzerland
PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 4:34 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

- Hanno_Spoelstra
That I would describe as "a Sherman" Wink


You can't have it that easy, you know Laughing


- Hanno_Spoelstra
As a curator I would place a sign describing of which components this Sherman was made up of, and why.


These days we are lucky if we can identify "which", "why" often remains a question without an answer, just like the tank in "Museo Carristi". We know that after WW II the Italian Army assembled Shermans out of anything available. At one point some turrets were used for fortifications. Later spare hulls were mixed with other turrets just for display/preservation purposes (most likely the case for the Sherman in Bologna).

Again, my point is that any categorization is arbitrary, but categorization are a necessity, so we have to live with the trade-off.

Massimo

PS You still have to tell me if a Sherman Firefly should be considered american or british Mr. Green
Back to top
View user's profile
Doug_Kibbey
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 23, 2006
Posts: 4678
Location: The Great Satan
PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 4:36 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

Actually, the thrust of my original question: "For Fireflies that had the 17lb. gun changed (or never actually installed) is there a visual cue that says "Yep, that was intended to be, or was at one time, a "Firefly"?"

...was intended to help me distinguish all other Shermans that had been modified from Fireflies that had been modified...so the presence or absence of the 17 pounder in later years is not what I was hoping to have as a criteria. In particular, I'm trying to distinguish between Argentina's many "repotenciados" many, if not most of which originated as Fireflies. For the ones that didn't have that origin, I'm wondering how one would tell.
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website Photo Gallery
Massimo_Foti
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Apr 08, 2008
Posts: 5397
Location: Lugano, Switzerland
PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 4:41 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

That was indeed an interesting question Doug. But we failed to resist the temptation to side-track the thread... Sorry

Massimo
Back to top
View user's profile
Massimo_Foti
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Apr 08, 2008
Posts: 5397
Location: Lugano, Switzerland
PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 4:45 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

Back to Doug's question. The original discussion around the Sherman in Rome was lost during a server crash here. But some comments are still available on Trevor's website and could help:
preservedtanks.com/Pro...4&Select=4

Massimo
Back to top
View user's profile
Doug_Kibbey
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Jan 23, 2006
Posts: 4678
Location: The Great Satan
PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 7:01 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

- Massimo_Foti
That was indeed an interesting question Doug. But we failed to resist the temptation to side-track the thread... Sorry

Massimo


Dangerous thread swerves are just an everyday hazard at the DG. Laughing
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website Photo Gallery
TrevorLarkum
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Sep 16, 2007
Posts: 1596
Location: Northampton, England
PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 10:21 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

- Hanno_Spoelstra
Trevor, we don't need curators' descriptions, they are notoriously bad as they don't wear anoraks like we do :lol:


True, but my point is that museums need to start caring about provenance, and that means starting with the serial number and researching a vehicle's history. It shouldn't be us doing their job for them. If it was an aircraft you can be sure they'd make more effort.


- Hanno_Spoelstra
A Firefly has a 17-pounder gun with all the amenities described above. So if someone re-converted a Sherman Firefly into another configuration, then the tank loses the "Firefly" tag (which is a nickname more than a proper designation, anyway).


To me the 'someone' is key. If a collector or re-enactor puts a Firefly turret on a standard Sherman I will record it as a standard Sherman, with a Firefly turret. If however the Italian or Belgian army puts a Firefly turret on a standard Sherman and it serves in that configuration then I record it as a Firefly (but an Italian or Belgian one, not a British one).


- Massimo_Foti

From what I can see Trevor's stance is "the hull rules", if the hull came from a Firefly, Trevor will flag it as a Firefly, basically, in the scenario above, he will pick the hull.


All other things being equal, yes that is correct. Hence the tanks I have recorded as Fireflies even though they no longer have a Firefly turret or 17pdr. However, that can be trumped (see the previous paragraph) - if a tank has served in an army as a Firefly (a Firefly turret on a different hull) then it's a Firefly. Even the first British Fireflies didn't have all the characteristics we now consider to indicate a Firefly, but they were Fireflies nonetheless.

Increasingly the best answer I am finding is to make clearer categories. Once I have more examples of a tank in the database I can make finer distinctions. In this case I will likely create categories for British, Italian and Belgian Fireflies, and the text will explain the characteristics in this case. For example, I am just getting to the point where I have started to do this with the M47 Patton with its Italian Service section.


- Massimo_Foti
Other may be facing even harder choices, for example, should we put Fireflies among american or british tanks? There no definitive answer to such a question...


This was a hard choice for me at one time and I agonised over it. I now absolutely define a tank by the nationality of its hull design, and have never regretted that move. For me the Firefly comes under Sherman tanks, which are under American tanks:

Preserved American Tanks: Volume 2

There are sections there for Fireflies, Ishermans, FL10s, etc. Having experience of writing about tank development it has become for me the only choice. When writing about the Firefly you need to have described the history and development of the Sherman, much less relevant is the history of British tanks. At first glance it may appear to throw up anomalies (e.g. the US M1917 and Soviet KS are in a chapter with the FT), but it very quickly makes perfect sense. My only regret is that I didn't follow it absolutely when I wrote Preserved German Tanks, and included the Hetzer, Marder I, etc. Now they would come under Czechoslovak and French tanks respectively.

_________________
Trevor

Dr Trevor Larkum
Preserved Tanks: PreservedTanks.com
Armour Archive: ArmourArchive.co.uk
EVs
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website
Tichenor
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Dec 06, 2007
Posts: 461
Location: Antwerp
PostPosted: Sat Feb 12, 2011 10:31 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

- Trevor
Once I have more examples of a tank in the database I can make finer distinctions. In this case I will likely create categories for British, Italian and Belgian Fireflies, and the text will explain the characteristics in this case.


This is going to be a hard nut to crack. As far as I know all the Firefly's in Belgium are original British build exempt maybe two ( the one in Leopoldsburg and a hull in Brasschaat). But even then there is no proof they where actualy rebuild after the war here in Belgium. But I have to say, some of the monuments here in Belgium are fore sure a mix of hulls and turrets (Hechtel, Hermeton-sur-meusse, Clermont, Mopertingen).

Michel
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website Photo Gallery
TrevorLarkum
Power User

Offline Offline
Joined: Sep 16, 2007
Posts: 1596
Location: Northampton, England
PostPosted: Sat Feb 12, 2011 11:23 pm
Post subject: Re: Question for the Sherman gurus...

If so, I'll classify them as British and make note of differences and exceptions. I look forward to writing up Belgium - I had a lot of fun in my youth cycling round and visiting old tanks - but it won't be for some time yet.

_________________
Trevor

Dr Trevor Larkum
Preserved Tanks: PreservedTanks.com
Armour Archive: ArmourArchive.co.uk
EVs
Back to top
View user's profile Visit poster's website
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic    Reply to topic    Printer Friendly Page    Forum Index ›  AFV News Discussion Board
Page 2 of 2
All times are GMT - 6 Hours
Go to page Previous  1, 2



Jump to:  


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You cannot download files in this forum